This Dvar Torah started formulating in my head a short while ago as I started getting ready for Shabbos, and I had to share it.
Here we are, fresh off of Teshuva Season 2012/5773. We made it through Elul with its selichos, crowned HaShem King on Rosh Hashana, endured the fast and fully repented on Yom Kippur, behaved as best as we could to ensure our inscription in the Book of Good Life was delivered on Hoshana Rabba, then celebrated with HaShem and His Torah over Shemini Atzeres and Simchas Torah.
Now what?
Chazal, in their wisdom, developed our Torah reading practice to end on Simchas Torah (or Shemini Atzeres for those in the Holy Land), and right away we begin with the introductory portion of Bereishis, the very first Parsha of the Chumash.
While there is much substance to the notion of showing our collective love and dedication to G-d's Torah so soon after our Days of Awe, I think that there is a more nuanced, deeper lesson to be derived as well.
One of the most infamous incidents of the entire Tanach takes place in this week's Parsha. Shortly after being informed that they can eat of any tree in the Garden of Eden except for the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Bad, Chava and subsequently Adam violate that commandment after some insidious plotting by the snake.
When confronted with their transgression, Adam, then Chava play the blame game. He points to her, she points to the snake, and everyone receives their particular punishment.
So soon after our annual Teshuva Season, we read of the very first humans and their example of how NOT to do Teshuva.
Instead of owning up to his own poor choice, Adam deflects responsibility entirely:
And the man said: 'The woman whom Thou gavest to be with me, she gave me of the tree, and I did eat.' (Bereishis 3:12)
Upon hearing this accusation, G-d turns to Chava for her response,
And the L-RD G-d said unto the woman: 'What is this thou hast done?' And the woman said: 'The serpent beguiled me, and I did eat.' (3:13)
G-d doesn't even give the snake a chance to defend itself, and starts off right away doling out punishment, beginning with the snake and moving onto Chava and then Adam.
On a literary side point - note the nifty repetition and reversal of the order of subjects: Adam is told the commandment and tells it to Chava who then repeats it to the snake, the snake convinces Chava who convinces Adam, G-d goes to Adam who blames Chava who blames the snake, and then G-d distributes punishment starting at the snake, then to Chava and back to Adam.
What should have happened?
Adam should have fessed up for his bad decision, not shifted the blame to his wife and partner. Chava in turn should have admitted to her own wrongdoing at choosing to follow the admittedly negative intentions of the snake.
Where do we see a model of this sort of proper teshuva, where the sinner admits to his transgression right away without batting an eye or rationalizing his behavior?
David Hamelech.
Centuries later, in the story told in Shmuel Bet chapters 11 and 12, David notices Batsheva, wife of Uria HaChiti and desires her. They sleep together, David subsequently has Uria sent off to die on the front lines of battle via his general Yoav, and he marries Batsheva. HaShem is not happy with this turn of events, for David has committed a most egregious sin.
HaShem sends the prophet Natan to rebuke David via a parable of a rich man stealing a poor man's lone lamb, which stirs up feelings of justice, leading him to say the rich man in the story should be put to death for his sin. Natan turns to David and says that he is the rich man of the story and he has sinned by having Uria killed and marrying Batsheva. He goes on to describe the forthcoming, very public and very damaging punishment that David has earned for his secretive sin.
Without any hesitation, and without batting an eye, King David immediately replies two words (12:13): "Chatasi LaShem" - "I have sinned against G-d."
Now THAT is teshuva.
The effectiveness of King David's teshuva is immediate:
And Nathan said unto David: 'The L-RD also hath put away thy sin; thou shalt not die. (12:13)
King David does not escape all punishment, and the child he has conceived with Batsheva will become sick and die. While he fasts and prays for mercy on behalf of his son while the child is ill, immediately after he dies, King David gets up from his fasting, washes, dresses, goes to the House of HaShem and bows, returns to his own home and eats, thus resuming his role of King of Israel.
His servants are baffled at the sudden diametrical shift in behavior. But King David replies to their questions by stating:
And he said: 'While the child was yet alive, I fasted and wept; for I said: Who knoweth whether the L-RD will not be gracious to me, that the child may live? But now he is dead, wherefore should I fast? can I bring him back again? I shall go to him, but he will not return to me.' (12:22-23).
Even after the tragic fulfillment of the punishment decreed by G-d, King David remains steadfast in his Teshuva. He knows there is the possibility that HaShem may show mercy, and still he accepts the judgement that has been passed on him because of his actions. He goes on to comfort his wife, Batsheva, and they later conceive Shlomo - his eventual successor to the throne.
We are human, and we will make mistakes and choose wrongly on occasion - just as we see with the very first humans beings created. It's part of our imperfect nature. HaShem knew this before we even existed, hence the Gemara in Pesachim 54A where Chazal tell us that Teshuva was one of the few things HaShem found important enough to create before our physical universe came into being.
Perhaps this connection further supports the Midrash in Yalkut Shimoni (Bereshis 41) that discusses how Adam was originally supposed to live for 1000 years, while King David was only supposed to live for 3 hours. Adam was told this information, and willingly "donated" 70 years of his life to David.
I don't know when this exchange took place, but based on what we've seen above, I would venture to say that it takes place after Adam ate from the Tree of Knowledge and received his punishment. It could very well be that Adam's motivation in doing so was also prophetically motivated - just as he knew David was supposed to live for such a short time, he saw David's potential and how he could become a role model for Teshuva in a way that Adam himself could and did not.
Let us take to heart the model of Teshuva as embodied by David HaMelech and not fall to playing the blame game as Adam and Chava did. In doing so, we can maintain the momentum of the growth and inspiration that we achieved during Teshuva Season 5773 - and even when we take a misstep here and there, we can bounce back with full repentance and further develop our devotion and connection to G-d.
Friday, October 12, 2012
How I Feel When I Lend A Single Guy My Tallis
I had received the aliyah immediately prior, and quickly turned to him and offered my tallis, which he gladly accepted and proceeded to make his berachos and receive his aliyah.
Some combination of the excitement/energy of the moment, along with the shiny metal plated atara (crown) of my tallis called to mind an image from my youth that perfectly suited the moment. I managed to track down the source and created this nifty animated gif.
Yes, it feels exactly like that. For all the male, unmarried readers - just wait until the first time a single guy asks to borrow your own tallis.
In case you're wondering what they're saying, here's the caption:
Red Ranger: Quick, Tommy, I need to borrow your tallis!
Green Ranger: Don't worry, Jason! Here you go!
Red Ranger: Totally Morphinominal! Thanks, bro!
Green Ranger: Anytime, man!
P.S. I apologize for the lack of regular updates. Now that the chagim are over, I hope to get back into things. I've missed writing about so many topics - Teshuva Season, Yomim Noraim, Sukkos, my 3rd Blogoversary...
Wednesday, September 12, 2012
Maccabeats Rosh Hashana Greetings
While not quite a full-fledged music video, the Maccabeats just released a video greeting card, wishing everyone a Shana Tova.
I think it's cute. The new official logo is rather spiffy, I must say.
I am also encouraged by the forthcoming great projects that are "in the works" for 5773, as stated in the description of the video. Sounds very exciting.
I look forward to their next video, whenever or for whichever holiday it may occur.
I think it's cute. The new official logo is rather spiffy, I must say.
I am also encouraged by the forthcoming great projects that are "in the works" for 5773, as stated in the description of the video. Sounds very exciting.
I look forward to their next video, whenever or for whichever holiday it may occur.
Labels:
Jewish Music,
Just for Fun,
Maccabeats,
Rosh Hashana,
YU
Lipa Schmeltzer's New Song/Video - "Mizrach"
While not Rosh Hashana related, Lipa has released a new music video for his song "Mizrach," which is dedicated to the Nachal Chareidi. It promotes unity among all the different groups within the Jewish People, which is always a noble goal, especially now around the Yomim Nora'im.
Ever since I first met/saw Lipa perform live at the 2nd YU-Nite Shabbaton in Stamford, Connecticut, I knew he was different from other performers out there from more right-wing backgrounds. After hearing him speak very positively about YU during the shabbaton as well as during his YU Chanukah performance, I became convinced that he is meant to be someone who uses his popularity and talent to greatly benefit the Jewish People.
Instead of merely created new engaging, inspiring and enjoyable music, he has become a personality for positive growth and unity - something we all need to focus on a little bit more these days, especially this time of the year.
I wish him much success, not only in his musical career, but in reaching out to Jews across the spectrum of Hashkafos and levels of religious observance - helping to bring us all a littler closer together.
Ever since I first met/saw Lipa perform live at the 2nd YU-Nite Shabbaton in Stamford, Connecticut, I knew he was different from other performers out there from more right-wing backgrounds. After hearing him speak very positively about YU during the shabbaton as well as during his YU Chanukah performance, I became convinced that he is meant to be someone who uses his popularity and talent to greatly benefit the Jewish People.
See Lipa singing that if he could do things over, he'd go to YU.
Instead of merely created new engaging, inspiring and enjoyable music, he has become a personality for positive growth and unity - something we all need to focus on a little bit more these days, especially this time of the year.
I wish him much success, not only in his musical career, but in reaching out to Jews across the spectrum of Hashkafos and levels of religious observance - helping to bring us all a littler closer together.
Thursday, September 6, 2012
Rosh Hashana 5773 Music Videos
Here we go! Another Rosh Hashana, another season of music videos!
From the Technion Institute in Israel - one of the most original, creative and fun videos I've ever seen.
From Aish.com we've got "What Makes Rosh Hashana Beautiful" based on a song by One Direction.
Disclaimer: The following videos feature women singing.
The Ein Prat Fountainheads are back with a new video for Sukkos called "Livin' in a Booth" based on Bruno Mars "Marry You."
UPDATE 9-12-12: Apparently, the Fountainheads have released a 2nd version of their video, "Livin' in a Booth." The music is the same, but there are different video segments/the video is cut differently. The 1st version is no longer accessible by searching on Youtube - but can be reached via a link, which I happen to have in the paragraph above ;)
The Jewish Agency in France has a video based on Carly Rae Jepson's "Call Me Maybe" entitled "Call Me Maybe - Chana Tova." I'm not sure what the lyrics mean since I don't know French. Also, apparently "ch" is used instead of "sh" in French.
While not a music video, WonderingJew presents a humorous video called "Yetzer Hara"
In terms of meaning and uplifting impact - I still think nothing can top "Book of Good Life" released by the Maccabeats this time last year...
If anyone has found any other music videos for Rosh Hashana, please post them in the comments and I'll update this post.
From the Technion Institute in Israel - one of the most original, creative and fun videos I've ever seen.
From Aish.com we've got "What Makes Rosh Hashana Beautiful" based on a song by One Direction.
UPDATE 9-12-12: The Maccabeats have released a cute Rosh Hashana greeting card video, featuring members of the group whistling the well-known Yomim Noraim niggun as they prepare for the Yom Tov!
UPDATE 9-13-12 - Also not a music video, but a great performance of "Chadesh Yameinu" by Shlomo Katz along with Rabbi Lazer Brody.
UPDATE 9-19-12: From Rabbi David Sirull of Augusta, Georgia, we have "Because It's Rosh Hashanah! A Musical Greeting"
Disclaimer: The following videos feature women singing.
The Ein Prat Fountainheads are back with a new video for Sukkos called "Livin' in a Booth" based on Bruno Mars "Marry You."
UPDATE 9-12-12: Apparently, the Fountainheads have released a 2nd version of their video, "Livin' in a Booth." The music is the same, but there are different video segments/the video is cut differently. The 1st version is no longer accessible by searching on Youtube - but can be reached via a link, which I happen to have in the paragraph above ;)
The Jewish Agency in France has a video based on Carly Rae Jepson's "Call Me Maybe" entitled "Call Me Maybe - Chana Tova." I'm not sure what the lyrics mean since I don't know French. Also, apparently "ch" is used instead of "sh" in French.
While not a music video, WonderingJew presents a humorous video called "Yetzer Hara"
In terms of meaning and uplifting impact - I still think nothing can top "Book of Good Life" released by the Maccabeats this time last year...
If anyone has found any other music videos for Rosh Hashana, please post them in the comments and I'll update this post.
Thursday, August 30, 2012
Thank G-d For All I Missed...?
While a lot of modern secular music today is utter trash - full of nivul peh, discussions about physical relationships, women's bodies, lustful desires and other inappropriate topics not worth singing about, there are still a few gems out there.
For some reason, on the days I've gotten tired of listening to the few Jewish Music CDs I have in my car (my older model vehicle doesn't have a multi-disc CD changer), I've been gravitating toward the local country station. Yes, go ahead and laugh if you'd like, but there are some very moving and inspirational songs to be found there. At the very least, there are definitely more worthwhile songs there than on the popular "90's, 2K, and today" stations.
I stumbled upon a song called "This" by Darius Rucker, once known many years ago for his band Hootie and the Blowfish (and their classic song "I Only Wanna Be With You").
In short, it's about a man reflecting on where life has taken him - or not taken him - along with his recognition and gratitude to G-d for arranging things the way they've happened. Despite the many setbacks and disappointments he's experienced, from the seemingly minor red traffic lights or the more major heartbreaks suffered from relationships that didn't work out - he's thankful for what he has and appreciates his life as it is.
For some reason, on the days I've gotten tired of listening to the few Jewish Music CDs I have in my car (my older model vehicle doesn't have a multi-disc CD changer), I've been gravitating toward the local country station. Yes, go ahead and laugh if you'd like, but there are some very moving and inspirational songs to be found there. At the very least, there are definitely more worthwhile songs there than on the popular "90's, 2K, and today" stations.
I stumbled upon a song called "This" by Darius Rucker, once known many years ago for his band Hootie and the Blowfish (and their classic song "I Only Wanna Be With You").
In short, it's about a man reflecting on where life has taken him - or not taken him - along with his recognition and gratitude to G-d for arranging things the way they've happened. Despite the many setbacks and disappointments he's experienced, from the seemingly minor red traffic lights or the more major heartbreaks suffered from relationships that didn't work out - he's thankful for what he has and appreciates his life as it is.
I don't really know how I got here
But I'm sure glad that I did
And it's crazy to think that one little thing
Could've changed all of it
How often do we take a step back to think about the process that led us to where we are now? I know I did this a lot when I was in yeshiva in Israel, and I began to see how many of the little, often complicated pieces of my life all came together to allow me to spend time learning in the holiest place on earth.
Of course, life being as busy as it always is, I fell out of that mindset after I got back to America and YU. Not only did I not think about the positive things or circumstances that brought me to where I was, my mind veered the other way entirely, and began to focus on the negative happenings that upset or disrupt my life. I am embarrassed to say that after some time, I seemed to focus on a string of negative experiences that appeared linked together - for the purpose of dragging me down.
Maybe it didn't turn out like I planned
Maybe that's why I'm such, such a lucky man
Despite all that, there is so much to be thankful for - no matter how rough or frustrating life may become. Man's plans can go totally awry, but nevertheless, it will work out in the end, if we give it time and proper consideration.
We can apply these thoughts to any area in life, but they are especially suited to dating, marriage and personal relationships. Often, when we get frustrated with how this are of our lives is going, we become resentful, wondering why we have to go through so much for seemingly so little gain - or what appears to be no gain at all. Yet, we don't know what will happen a year from now, six months from now, a week from now or even tomorrow. Things can and do turn around in ways that we don't expect because we aren't privy to the whole picture.
I didn't understand it way back when
But sitting here right now it all makes perfect sense
It may not make "perfect" sense, since nothing in our human realm is ever really perfect, especially our understanding of how life works, but it will make some worthwhile sense.
One day, hopefully sooner than later, the process of dating, meeting people, forming connections, making phone call after phone call, dressing up and going out again and again will come to an end.
For those of us who are already married, I can speak from personal experience that marriage is definitely a beginning rather than an ending, with its own trials and tribulations, its highs and lows, the full spectrum of emotions. Figuring all that out, discovering more about your new life partner as well as learning more about yourself and how you work - which you would NEVER have thought through as a single person, can be maddening.
All the fights and tears and the heartache
I thought I'd never go through
And the moment I almost gave up
All lead me here to you
Yet, if we all take a step back and try to see the bigger picture we can be appreciative of what we have and how we got here. The journey may be rough at times, but we're still here, right? For every opportunity you've had but lost, felt like you failed, or reached a hopeless dead end, think more deeply and wonder where you were able to go on from there, precisely because of this roadblock that frustrated you at the time.
Don't think about what could have been had you succeeded there, because there is no use crying over spilled milk. What did you do in that situation? How did you move on and to where? More importantly, where are you now? How did that event affect you, positively or negatively and lead you to where you are and who you have become? Did you use those "missed" opportunities for what they really were - a chance for growth, or did you stew in misery? Even if you didn't learn something then, what can you learn from it to apply to life in the here and now?
All the doors I had to close
All the things I knew but I didn't know
Thank G-d for all I missed
Because it led me here to this
This mindset is particularly appropriate for the month of Elul, when we should be focusing on the past year and the things we've done and experienced. If we can see our mistakes and other negative moments in life in a positive light, to draw strength and inspiration from them, we can use that to turn even our aveiros into mitzvos, regretting the negative but learning from our actions to propel us forward into a better, more informed future.
May we all appreciate all the things we've missed, tap into that source of inspiration for the good.
We can apply these thoughts to any area in life, but they are especially suited to dating, marriage and personal relationships. Often, when we get frustrated with how this are of our lives is going, we become resentful, wondering why we have to go through so much for seemingly so little gain - or what appears to be no gain at all. Yet, we don't know what will happen a year from now, six months from now, a week from now or even tomorrow. Things can and do turn around in ways that we don't expect because we aren't privy to the whole picture.
I didn't understand it way back when
But sitting here right now it all makes perfect sense
It may not make "perfect" sense, since nothing in our human realm is ever really perfect, especially our understanding of how life works, but it will make some worthwhile sense.
One day, hopefully sooner than later, the process of dating, meeting people, forming connections, making phone call after phone call, dressing up and going out again and again will come to an end.
For those of us who are already married, I can speak from personal experience that marriage is definitely a beginning rather than an ending, with its own trials and tribulations, its highs and lows, the full spectrum of emotions. Figuring all that out, discovering more about your new life partner as well as learning more about yourself and how you work - which you would NEVER have thought through as a single person, can be maddening.
All the fights and tears and the heartache
I thought I'd never go through
And the moment I almost gave up
All lead me here to you
Yet, if we all take a step back and try to see the bigger picture we can be appreciative of what we have and how we got here. The journey may be rough at times, but we're still here, right? For every opportunity you've had but lost, felt like you failed, or reached a hopeless dead end, think more deeply and wonder where you were able to go on from there, precisely because of this roadblock that frustrated you at the time.
Don't think about what could have been had you succeeded there, because there is no use crying over spilled milk. What did you do in that situation? How did you move on and to where? More importantly, where are you now? How did that event affect you, positively or negatively and lead you to where you are and who you have become? Did you use those "missed" opportunities for what they really were - a chance for growth, or did you stew in misery? Even if you didn't learn something then, what can you learn from it to apply to life in the here and now?
All the doors I had to close
All the things I knew but I didn't know
Thank G-d for all I missed
Because it led me here to this
This mindset is particularly appropriate for the month of Elul, when we should be focusing on the past year and the things we've done and experienced. If we can see our mistakes and other negative moments in life in a positive light, to draw strength and inspiration from them, we can use that to turn even our aveiros into mitzvos, regretting the negative but learning from our actions to propel us forward into a better, more informed future.
May we all appreciate all the things we've missed, tap into that source of inspiration for the good.
Labels:
dating,
Elul,
marriage,
mussar,
Rosh Hashana,
shidduchim,
spirituality,
teshuva,
Yom Kippur
Tuesday, July 24, 2012
A Taste Of Things To Come
This past Shabbos, I was learning the sefer Imrei Baruch by Rav Baruch Simon, a Rosh Yeshiva at YU, and wanted to share two pieces that I found there that are related to the period of the 3 Weeks and Tisha B'Av.
The Gemara in the tractate of Ta’anis (30B) says that anyone
who mourns for Yerushalayim will merit to see it in its rejoicing, and one who
does not mourn for Yerushalayim will not see its rejoicing. The Maharal in the
23rd chapter of his work, Netach Yisrael explains this Gemara. He
writes that one who knows he is lacking something in his life can look forward
to something that will complete his existence, but someone who feels as though his
life is already complete cannot feel a sense of longing for anything. Thus,
according to the Gemara, one who actively mourns for Yerushalayim has cultivated
within himself a vacant space that will be filled with the joy of Yerushalayim’s
rebuilding. By contrast, one who believes that life is great the way it is has
no ability to appreciate a future that has been completed by the rebuilding of
the Beis Hamikdash, and thus cannot experience it.
Rav Simon adds that it appears as though Hashem is acting
toward the person in a midah k’neged midah (measure for measure) fashion.
Someone who considers Yerushalayim important enough in their hearts to realize
he is incomplete without the city and Temple standing in their grandeur will
merit to have that hole in his life filled by the comfort of the city’s
rejoicing. By contrast, one who believes his existence his full and perfect
without Yerushalayim are excluded, since he feels there is nothing missing in
his life.
The Chasam Sofer elaborates on a very interesting concept
related to this tradition that one who mourns for Yerushalayim will merit to
see it be comforted. He notes that the word “to see” is written in present, not
future tense, as one might expect. The reason is due to the wholly different
nature of our mourning for Yerushalayim, when compared to other nations’
response to past tragedies. For other nations in the world who take time to
remember tragic events in their history, there is a sense of total loss, of
remembering what is no longer here and gone forever. This is not so by the
Jewish people and our mourning for Yerushalayim. As we know from the story of
Yaakov and Yosef’s sale, Yaakov would not be comforted despite his children’s
best efforts. There, Rashi explains that this was because the natural order
created by Hashem is that a person should gradually find solace and begin to
forget the intense pain of a true loss of life as time goes by, a phenomenon
which does not exist for someone who is missing but still alive and could
return. So too is it with our mourning for Yerushalayim. While we are saddened
by its absence in our lives, we know, deep down, that one day (hopefully soon) Moshiach
will come and we will once again be able to experience the spiritual splendor
of the Beis Hamikdash, just as we did in times of old.
This year, Tisha B’Av falls out on Shabbos, which means the
observance of the fast itself will be pushed off until Motzei Shabbos and
Sunday. When I first realized this, I thought that for once the Jewish people
would be observing the opinion of Rabbi Yochanan, who says that had he been
there when the fast day was established, he would have made it on the 10th
of Av, since the majority of the Beis Hamikdash burned then and only started to
burn on the 9th. However, it still didn’t quite sit well with me
that I’d be spending the actual day of Tisha B’Av enjoying Shabbos, eating
foods, singing zemiros, and spending time with friends and family.
Then it hit me.
We are all aware of the idea that Tisha B’Av is called a “moed”
or holiday, based on the verse in Eicha 1:15. Based on this, we don’t say
tachanun during the day, and the rabbis tell us that in the future, Tisha B’Av
will actually become a day of celebration once the Beis Hamikdash is rebuilt.
This, of course, means that the day will be transformed from one of sitting on
the floor, fasting, refraining from greeting one another to a day of dancing,
feasting and rejoicing.
This year, due to the structure of our calendar, we are
privileged to have a taste of things to come. We will be able to experience
Tisha B’Av as it is meant to be experienced, not as a day of mourning but as
one of celebration. True, we must not let this idea go to our heads and cause
us to forget the fact of the matter that the Beis Hamikdash is not yet rebuilt,
but I hope we can utilize this opportunity to prepare our minds for the great
change that will occur with Moshaich’s arrival.
Hopefully, this year’s observance of Shabbos on Tisha B’Av
will prepare us all for the true celebration and happiness we will experience
next year with the coming of Moshiach and the rebuilding of the 3rd
and final Beis Hamikdash!
Wednesday, July 11, 2012
Save The Worms - Lend A Helping Hand
It happens almost every day, and each time I see the aftermath I feel saddened and helpless.
I'm walking down the sidewalk, typically going into or leaving my apartment and I notice a curled up, crispy little creature frozen in time, its last moments captured in some horrific, painful-looking expression of death .
What am I talking about? Earthworms.
| Your friendly neighborhood soil processor. Source: wikimedia.org |
While I used to think these little guys surfaced after it rained to avoid drowning, it turns out the real reason is because they utilize the moistened environment to move around above ground, a faster mode of transport than burrowing through the dirt, their typical means of travel which helps avoid becoming dried out.
I have noticed worms crawling across the sidewalk in the early morning on my way to shul for Shacharis. In the afternoons, as I return for Mincha/Ma'ariv, I often spot unfortunate worms who didn't quite make it back into a nearby dirt-covered area before the midday sun baked them into something that looks like this:
| Source: http://southfloridadaily.com/ |
In the worst cases, the poor critters are frozen in time, reaching upward as though begging G-d Himself to help them find shelter as their body dehydrates and dies millimeter by millimeter. I imagine that experience is excruciatingly painful, but I am thankful that the worms don't possess a higher sentience that allows them to dwell on their misery in some philosophical/ existential fashion as they progressively exit their mortal existence.
So what's with all this worm musing?
Sometimes we see people we know struggling with a difficulty in life. Trying to make it from point A to point B, but for whatever reason they can't quite make it, and may very well fail in their attempt. It could be that they don't possess all the faculties or resources to be able to accomplish the goal for which they have the desire.
As much as we are taught to believe that G-d does not give us challenges that we cannot overcome, I do not think that this means we, as individuals, must approach these obstacles alone. The very fact that you witness someone struggling means that you had the opportunity to see them in their state of need means that you are now connected with their travail, however minor your observance of their toil might be.
Whether it's someone struggling in Torah learning, trying to accept upon themselves the observance or improved observance of a particular mitzvah, difficulty dating, conflicts with friends, teachers, or parents, or just about anything else out there - it would behoove us to think about how we can help the person achieve what they are trying to accomplish.
Our effort could be as extensive as offering to work closely with the person to facilitate their success, becoming their chevrusa, dating mentor, shoulder to cry on, ear to listen, or as seemingly minor as offering a word of encouragement or pointing them in the right direction, letting them know where they can get help, or telling them you've also struggled with this area and would be glad to lend a hand where possible.
Every time I see an earthworm making its way across the damp morning sidewalk - or especially if it is later in the day and the temperature along with the sun's radiance is increasing - I take a moment to crouch down and move the little guy into a shady grassy/dirt covered area nearby. It's such a minimal effort, but it saves the worm from a terrible death.
We must be cognizant of those around us, especially those close to us, those we hold near and dear in our hearts and minds, and not stand still while they frustrate themselves with something that may be just beyond their reach. Just like that earthworm that was inches away from the grass before it was crispified by the sun, we could reach out and give those people the small little boost of support they need to succeed for themselves.
May we all look out for one another, in ways both big and small, and create a more unified Jewish people as a result of our efforts.
Labels:
dating,
hashkafa,
life,
mussar,
spirituality
Tuesday, June 26, 2012
Why Did Miriam Die?
While doing shnaim mikrah v'echad targum this week, a question popped into my mind that I hadn't thought of before.
In this week's parsha of Chukas, we have the infamous incident of Moshe becoming angry and striking the rock instead of speaking to it as instructed by HaShem. For this action (or perhaps his anger) he and Aharon are denied the privilege of entering Eretz Canaan.
However, earlier in the parsha, Miriam dies for some unexplained reason. Rashi's first comment there is about the juxtaposition of her death to the Para Aduma - which is a hotly debated subject in its own right. The second, which other commentators echo, is related to the fact that she her actual death was due to receiving a kiss from HaShem. After checking the Mikraos Gedolos Hame'or, it seems that no mainstream commentator writes anything about this enigma.
Miriam, being female, should have been allowed to enter the land just like all the other women who weren't participants in the mass hysteria caused by listening to the spies' negative report.
So why did she die now, before she was able to enter Canaan?
My first theory is that since she was the oldest sibling, perhaps it was just her time - her death took place at the start of the 40th year of traveling in the desert after all.
Or, in an interesting twist - she died because Moshe and Aharon were going to die and not enter the land. There is some textual evidence, as well as further remarks in Shas/Midrashim that indicate she was a leader among the women akin to Moshe and Aharon's roles as leaders. If they weren't going to enter the land, it probably wouldn't be fair to Yehoshua to have a previous generation leader still around, perhaps #3 on the overall totem pole in terms of greatness and prophecy. She also probably didn't have the character type like Devorah did later on in Shoftim, who actively judged, led, and went into battle. The job of Moshe's successor was going to be a hectic and demanding one, and it may not have fit her personal strengths.
This second idea, unlike the first doesn't explain why she died BEFORE Moshe hit the rock and he and Aharon received their punishment.
I'm somewhat surprised that I've never heard anyone talk about this before in a shiur or dvar Torah. If the meforshim don't mention it, there must be something pretty simple that I'm missing...
Has anyone heard/learnt anything about Miriam's death?
UPDATE: 10:55 PM - after a bit of Googling, I found that Rav Zev Leff was asked this question. In short, he quotes a Zohar (which is further elaborated in the Netziv) that says since this was a transitional period for Bnei Yisrael, they had to stop relying on open miracles - here, her rock-well that provided water - and instead learn how to live a more "natural" existence of hidden miracles, which would include praying to HaShem for rain. Rav Leff further explains that Miriam died without the miracles that accompanied Moshe and Aharon's deaths (but didn't she get the kiss from HaShem?), which allowed her to become a bridge of sorts between these two periods. The people, by not eulogizing her, failed to get this point. Additionally, the Netziv adds that "speaking" to the rock instead of hitting it as before represented a process more akin to what they would do in Eretz Yisrael, as previously mentioned, by davening to receive rain.
With all due respect, while interesting, I find this explanation a bit unsatisfying. As I've learned more in Yeshiva in Israel and at YU (particularly in Rabbi Hayyim Angel's shiur), I want to find some sort of pshat based in the psukim to help clarify what was going on with Miriam's death... So please leave a comment if you've heard anything on this subject.
In this week's parsha of Chukas, we have the infamous incident of Moshe becoming angry and striking the rock instead of speaking to it as instructed by HaShem. For this action (or perhaps his anger) he and Aharon are denied the privilege of entering Eretz Canaan.
However, earlier in the parsha, Miriam dies for some unexplained reason. Rashi's first comment there is about the juxtaposition of her death to the Para Aduma - which is a hotly debated subject in its own right. The second, which other commentators echo, is related to the fact that she her actual death was due to receiving a kiss from HaShem. After checking the Mikraos Gedolos Hame'or, it seems that no mainstream commentator writes anything about this enigma.
Miriam, being female, should have been allowed to enter the land just like all the other women who weren't participants in the mass hysteria caused by listening to the spies' negative report.
So why did she die now, before she was able to enter Canaan?
My first theory is that since she was the oldest sibling, perhaps it was just her time - her death took place at the start of the 40th year of traveling in the desert after all.
Or, in an interesting twist - she died because Moshe and Aharon were going to die and not enter the land. There is some textual evidence, as well as further remarks in Shas/Midrashim that indicate she was a leader among the women akin to Moshe and Aharon's roles as leaders. If they weren't going to enter the land, it probably wouldn't be fair to Yehoshua to have a previous generation leader still around, perhaps #3 on the overall totem pole in terms of greatness and prophecy. She also probably didn't have the character type like Devorah did later on in Shoftim, who actively judged, led, and went into battle. The job of Moshe's successor was going to be a hectic and demanding one, and it may not have fit her personal strengths.
This second idea, unlike the first doesn't explain why she died BEFORE Moshe hit the rock and he and Aharon received their punishment.
I'm somewhat surprised that I've never heard anyone talk about this before in a shiur or dvar Torah. If the meforshim don't mention it, there must be something pretty simple that I'm missing...
Has anyone heard/learnt anything about Miriam's death?
UPDATE: 10:55 PM - after a bit of Googling, I found that Rav Zev Leff was asked this question. In short, he quotes a Zohar (which is further elaborated in the Netziv) that says since this was a transitional period for Bnei Yisrael, they had to stop relying on open miracles - here, her rock-well that provided water - and instead learn how to live a more "natural" existence of hidden miracles, which would include praying to HaShem for rain. Rav Leff further explains that Miriam died without the miracles that accompanied Moshe and Aharon's deaths (but didn't she get the kiss from HaShem?), which allowed her to become a bridge of sorts between these two periods. The people, by not eulogizing her, failed to get this point. Additionally, the Netziv adds that "speaking" to the rock instead of hitting it as before represented a process more akin to what they would do in Eretz Yisrael, as previously mentioned, by davening to receive rain.
With all due respect, while interesting, I find this explanation a bit unsatisfying. As I've learned more in Yeshiva in Israel and at YU (particularly in Rabbi Hayyim Angel's shiur), I want to find some sort of pshat based in the psukim to help clarify what was going on with Miriam's death... So please leave a comment if you've heard anything on this subject.
Tuesday, June 12, 2012
They Might Be Giants...
In this week’s Parsha of Shelach, we encounter the tragic
incident of the spies. Sent by Moshe at the request of the people, ten of these
twelve men of stature return from their 40-day sojourn in the land of Canaan
with a negative, discouraging report that greatly frightens Bnei Yisrael,
thereby inducing a mass hysteria. This
terrified reaction leads to Hashem’s proclamation that the entire generation
that unjustly bemoaned why they ever left Egypt will not merit inheriting the
land promised to their forefathers.
What was the main problem in the spies report? Some
commentators focus on the fact that they incorrectly gave an assessment of Bnei
Yisrael’s capability to fight the
Canaanites instead of assessing the goodness of the land, thereby ignoring
Moshe’s instructions; they were sent to survey the territory, not formulate a
strategy for the forthcoming battles.
I would like to offer a different approach that emphasizes
the perspective and message that was delivered, which will hopefully
demonstrate the problematic nature of the spies’ report.
After their initial remarks, and the
encouraging but failed counter-protest by Calev, the spies conclude their
dismal presentation by saying “…And there we saw the Nephilim, the sons of
Anak, who come of the Nephilim; and we were in our own sight as grasshoppers,
and so we were in their sight'” (Bamidbar 13:33).
The word “Nephilim” is typically translated
as giants, and these residents of Canaan indeed were physically large as well
as experienced warriors. It is also true that by this point in time, Bnei
Yisrael had not fought in many battles. However, they had seen the powerful outstretched arm of Hashem miraculously wipe
out the Egyptian people and its army and had heard Hashem promise that He would
again intervene in their forthcoming campaign to conquer Canaan.
Yet, what exactly did the spies say? They
claimed that “we were in our own sight as grasshoppers,” a remark spoken from
their own perspective, which minimized their personal significance and talents.
They then went further to conjecture from the viewpoint of the giants, placing
unexpressed thoughts into their minds and words into their mouths. Regardless
of what the Nephilim did or didn’t say (see the tractate of Sotah 3A where this
is discussed), the central issue at hand is the spies’ self-abnegation. The
spies perceived themselves as grasshoppers – and because they conceived
themselves as such, they became what
they feared. Only after they declare “we were in our own sight as grasshoppers” then they concluded “and so we were in their sight.’”
It is interesting to note that the spies
chose the image of a “chagav” or “grasshopper” to demonstrate their misperceived
weakness. This exact phraseology is used again in a similar deprecating fashion
later in Tanach in the book of Yeshaya, where the verse says, “The One Who sits
above the circle of the earth, and those who inhabit it are as grasshoppers”
(40:22). Clearly,
being compared to a grasshopper is not a favorable metaphor.
However, I think this is where the spies
missed the point. True, the giants were physically larger and mightier than
Bnei Yisrael, and had fought in countless wars that honed the skills of their
army while we spent centuries in slavery. Indeed, this mere fact could make us
feel like insects in their sight. But, there is another, related creature that
the spies, and in reality, all of Bnei Yisrael had recently witnessed that
wrought tremendous destructive power despite its small size: the locust.
| An Egyptian locust |
| A giant locust swarm |
| A swarm of locusts devouring vegetation in the Mexican State of Yucatan |
Alas, this was not to be.
However, we can learn from this entomology
lesson (entomology is the study of insects) and strive to avoid making the same
mistake the spies made. We should recognize the harmful properties of
projecting a negative, self-deprecating image of ourselves; it can become an unfortunate, self-destructive reality. We should also take to heart the concept
presented in Mishlei 14:28, “B’rov Am Hadras Melech” or “In the multitudes
there is glorification of the King.” We are not comparable to lone
grasshoppers, but to locusts, who join together for a purpose larger and more
significant than we may realize. A minyan of ten men can accomplish more than a
single man praying alone, and the totality of the Jewish People gathered
together, joining our unique individualities in the service of Hashem, can
accomplish miraculous feats the likes of which the world cannot begin to
imagine. Together, and only together, with the light of the Torah as our guide,
can we achieve what may otherwise seem impossible.
Labels:
Dvar Torah,
hashkafa,
mussar,
Torah,
Weekly Parsha
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)